Collection Spotlight

Shortlist | Archiving as an Asian Art Practice

Shortlists offer thematic selections from AAA’s Collection, including overviews and annotations by invited contributors. The following shortlist by the Kaohsiung-based scholar and curator Huang Chien-Hung focuses on archival art in Asia.

 

Introduction

Archival art became a much discussed form in international art circles just when China and new markets in Asia began their ascent, yet its classification remains imprecise. The Asian situation became another aspect for consideration when constructing a notion of archival art; and the unique history and development of Asia make it such that concepts of archival types, standards, and classification must be considered in close relation to history and geopolitical developments. Therefore, this listing of Asian archival art is not archetypal, but rather more like a migrant archival network resembling an archipelago. Archival art under these unique developmental conditions is not just a vehicle for expression different from others, but is also inscribed with historical experiences, political situations, and cultural boundaries.

The first qualitative change took place in the first thirty years of the twentieth century, when archiving was put to use as montage. This expanded possibilities for creating narratives with contextualised material and was a project that involved both Constructivists and Surrealists. The second change came in the 1950s with a growing interest in semiotics, which set in motion structuralist readings of the symbol-filled commodities of consumer society and the creation of categorised archive databases. The third period of change was launched by Foucault's critique of knowledge and Derrida's critique of writing, thus opening the knowledge channels of meta-political critique in this period of deconstruction. Toward the end of the 1990s and beginning of the twenty-first century, the high tide of globalisation brought a surge in the reprocessing of multicultural information and its flow. Prepackaged information, analytic animations, and field reports became ways of organising and utilising archives during a period of environmental crises and competition for resources. This period could be called the anthropological period. No doubt, in this evolution, we can see Hal Foster's deconstruction of the archival impulse; Okwui Enwezor's reference to, by way of postcolonial theory, an ethical image archive similar to the Society of the Spectacle; or Boris Groys's biopolitics as an observational orientation, which imbues documentation and archives with a Benjaminian aura.

However, in Asia, during the period of colonial and Cold War autocratic rule, archiving was prevented by mechanisms of authority, so we had to wait for globalisation's promise of democratisation. It wasn't until the 1980s that archiving entered the field of artistic expression in Asia, and an influx of postmodern trends contributed to Asia's Pop Art period. A great number of portraits concerning the Cold War and fascist regimes, consumer society's political propaganda, and advertising imagery all became quotable or appropriable subject matter for art. Following the development of biennials and urban areas in the 1990s, Asian cities relied on changes to their urban scenery and unique cultural qualities to promote themselves. Archival documentation of the growth of metropolises, concentration of labour, production of surplus, and even creation of folk arts began to appear in contemporary art forms such as digital prints, installations, documentary films, and writing. Overall, this second evolution could be called the knowledge economy period. Following this, Asian academia continued to emphasise the archiving of European and North American art history under the sway of cultural imperialism. New glocal identities were formed in the prospering economies of Asia facing the inevitability of globalisation, and Asian artists first started producing political art resisting global capitalism and participatory art resisting the appropriation of domestic capital. Furthermore, as these new glocal identities tending toward a multitude joined the West's anthropological period, items such as historical archives, recorded oral narratives, family photographs, and OEM products became elements in postcolonial readings, interpretations, and narratives. This third phase could be called the people's writing period.

It has been difficult for archival art in Asia to follow the same historical trajectory as it did in Europe and North America where archiving became an ideology unifying continents. It therefore did not evolve into the phase of Derrida's domestic affairs, nor could it replicate Foucault's meta-critique. As a result, it would be best for Asia to form a migrant archive network in the form of an archipelago. First and foremost, migrant archiving means turning some object into an archive. This process often involves dispersed and moving life, which suggests the impossibility of using the borders of a modern country to map the collection of archives. Rather, national borders must be transcended when the structure of archiving is being contemplated, and moving processes and topological networks must be used when considering the archiving of that object. Finally, aside from this analysis, the use of and interactions between archives are also important, as they exist in a Deleuzian state of becoming. Moreover, Asian artists engaged in postcolonial issues are no longer dealing with problems of cultural difference, but are directly facing struggles and reconciliation between the values of foreign countries and local societies. Therefore, archiving must create a space where restatements of history, records of culture, and perspectives of society can be reconciled and weave a memorial from aphasic bodies, dispersed life and family histories, and schizophrenics. Perhaps this communication field will not only serve as a place of redemption in the name of animism, but also a spiritual space based on connection and cooperation.

Asia needs to build a new field of cross-cultural communication on a foundation of migrant archiving. Relying on the presentation of a large amount of regional or shamanistic archival materials—even though these materials transcend modernity—cannot rescue us from our experience of postcolonialism. Furthermore, any nominalistic attempt to define Asia is uninteresting because in reality Asia is always shifting. For example, when Ho Tzu Nyen made The Critical Dictionary of Southeast Asia, Vol. 1: G for Ghost(writers), he could not develop his archival work based on chronological order or the geographical borders of countries, so instead he chose to collect vast amounts of information from the Internet, compile and summarise the information, and then piece together different regional historical moments of South East Asia for presentation. In his The Bianwen Book, Chen Chieh-jen discusses figures of various historical and cultural contexts, social situations, or political moments that practice resistance. And Pak Sheung Chuen used biographical survey in his work Familiar Numbers, Unknown Telephone, which became a geopolitical and historical archive in his subsequent work Meeting with Mr. Bus After Ten Years.

 

Recommended Readings

 

Ahn, Sohyun, ed. Trans-Theatre. Forum A, Seoul, 2016. [Korean & English] MON.JEY

Back, Seung Woo. Seung Woo Back Portfolio: 2002–2016. Independently published, 2017. [Korean & English] MONL.BSW

Badovinac, Zdenka, et.al., eds. NSK From Kapital to Capital. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2015. [English] MON.NSK2

Chang, Wen-hsuan. The Compendium of Autobiographies. Tainan: Fotoaura Institute of Photography, 2016. [Traditional Chinese & English] 張紋瑄,《自傳大系》,海馬迴光畫館,台南,2016。 [繁體中文及英文] MON.CWH3

Chen, Chieh-jen. The Bianwen Book. Independently published, 2017. [Traditional Chinese] 陳界仁,《變文書》,獨立出版,2017。[繁體中文] (available soon)

Didi-Huberman, Georges. The Burned Memory. Beijing: China Nationality Photographic Art Publishing House, 2015. [Simplified Chinese & French] 喬治∙廸廸∙于貝爾曼,《記憶的灼痛》,中國民族攝影藝術出版社,北京,2015。 [簡體中文及法文] EX.CHN.LMB

Enwezor, Okwui. Archive Fever: Uses of the Document in Contemporary Art. New York: International Center of Photography, 2008. [English] EX.USA.AFU

Foster, Hal. Bad New Days: Art, Criticism, Emergency. London: Verso, 2017. [English] REF.FOH

Ginwala, Natasha, ed. My East is Your West. New York: HarperCollins, 2016. [English] EX.ITA.MEI

Gleeson, Erin. Arin Rungjang: Mongkut. Paris: Jeu De Paume, 2015. [French & English] MON.RUA3

Groys, Boris. Art Power. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2008. [English] REF.GRB2

Ho, Tzu Nyen. The Critical Dictionary of Southeast Asia, Vol. 1: G for Ghost(writers), 2017. Accessed November 8, 2017. 何子彥,《東南亞關鍵詞典「G」條: 鬼影寫手》,2017。檢索日期: 2017年11月8日。https://aaa.cdosea.org/#video/a

Knes, Heinz Peter Knes, Danh Vo, and Amy Zion. Hannah Arendt Library. Independently published, 2012. [English] REF.VOD (Closed Stack)

Kuswidananto, Jompet. Jompet Kuswidananto: After Voices. Sydney: Sherman Contemporary Art Foundation, 2016. [English] MON.KUJ

Lee, Lisa, and Hal Foster, eds. Critical Laboratory: The Writings of Thomas Hirschhorn. Cambridge: MIT Press, 2013. [English] REF.FOH

Singh, Dakshita. “Lala from Lahore.” Accessed September 5, 2017. http://zubaanbooks.com/2015/07/ [English] CLP.15.07

Wang, Jing, and Xu Tan, eds. Xu Tan: Keywords of Cowin Global. Guangzhou: Vitamin Creative Space, 2010. [Simplified Chinese & English] 王景,徐坦編,《徐坦: "科雲"的詞》,維他命藝術空間,廣州,2010。[簡體中文及英文] MON.XUT

Weerasethakul, Apichatpong, ed. Apichatpong Weerasethakul Sourcebook: The Serenity of Madness. New York: Independent Curators International, 2016. [Thai & English] MON.WEA2

“Plates: Pak Sheung Chuen.” In Discordant Harmony: Critical Reflection on the Imagination of Asia, edited by Chu The-I, 122–125. Taipei: Kuandu Museum of Fine Arts, Taipei National University of the Arts, 2016. [Traditional Chinese & English] 〈作品圖版: 白雙全〉,曲德益編,《失調的和諧:關於亞洲想像的批判反思》,國立臺北藝術大學關渡美術館,臺北,2016,頁122–125。[繁體中文及英文] EX.TAI.DTH

 

 

Huang Chien-Hung is Associate Professor, Graduate Institute of Interdisciplinary Art, National Kaohsiung Normal University.

Imprint

Author

HUANG Chienhung, 黃建宏

Topic
Collection Spotlight

Relevant content

Boris Groys Art Power (Detail)
Boris Groys in Conversation with Johnson Chang
Ideas | Conversations

Boris Groys in Conversation with Johnson Chang

On archives as “museums minus the aesthetic experience,” the return of God as a spectator, and the totalitarianism of music

Image: Covers of the periodical <i>Free World</i>.
Periodicals, American Interventions, and Art in Asia During the Cold War
Ideas | Notes

Periodicals, American Interventions, and Art in Asia During the Cold War

On Ho Tzu Nyen's research in relation to items in the Ha Bik Chuen Archive

Ho Tzu Nyen The Name (Still)
Ho Tzu Nyen on The Critical Dictionary of Southeast Asia
Ideas | Conversations

Ho Tzu Nyen on The Critical Dictionary of Southeast Asia

The Singaporean artist discusses tigers, ghosts, algorithms, and life after celluloid film

The Nameless
The Ground Underneath: On Ho Tzu Nyen's The Nameless
Ideas | Notes

The Ground Underneath: On Ho Tzu Nyen's The Nameless

Võ Hồng Chương-Đài examines how Ho's video installation acts as a non sequitur to colonialist and nationalist historiographies

Trans-Theatre
Trans-Theatre
Monograph

Trans-Theatre

전환극장
2016

Seung Woo Back Portfolio: 2002–2016
Seung Woo Back Portfolio: 2002–2016
Monograph

Seung Woo Back Portfolio: 2002–2016

2017

NSK from Kapital to Capital
NSK from Kapital to Capital: Neue Slowenische Kunst – An Event of the Final Decade of Yugoslavia
Monograph

NSK from Kapital to Capital: Neue Slowenische Kunst – An Event of the Final Decade of Yugoslavia

2015

The_Compendium_of_Autobiographies
The Compendium of Autobiographies
Monograph

The Compendium of Autobiographies

自傳大系
2016

The Burned Memory
The Burned Memory
Exhibition Catalogue

The Burned Memory

記憶的灼痛
Georges DIDI-HUBERMAN
2015

Archive Fever: Uses of the Document in Contemporary Art
Archive Fever: Uses of the Document in Contemporary Art
Exhibition Catalogue

Archive Fever: Uses of the Document in Contemporary Art

Okwui ENWEZOR
2008

Bad New Days
Bad New Days: Art, Criticism, Emergency
Reference

Bad New Days: Art, Criticism, Emergency

Hal FOSTER
2017

My East is Your West: A Collateral Event at the 56th Venice Biennale
My East is Your West: A Collateral Event at the 56th Venice Biennale
Exhibition Catalogue

My East is Your West: A Collateral Event at the 56th Venice Biennale

2016

Arin Rungjang: Mongkut
Arin Rungjang: Mongkut
Monograph

Arin Rungjang: Mongkut

2015

Art Power
Art Power
Reference

Art Power

Boris GROYS
2008

Hannah Arendt's Library
Hannah Arendt's Library
Reference

Hannah Arendt's Library

2012

Jompet Kuswidananto: After Voices
Jompet Kuswidananto: After Voices
Monograph

Jompet Kuswidananto: After Voices

2016

Critical Laboratory: The Writings of Thomas Hirschhorn
Critical Laboratory: The Writings of Thomas Hirschhorn
Reference

Critical Laboratory: The Writings of Thomas Hirschhorn

Thomas HIRSCHHORN
2013

Lala from Lahore
clipping

Lala from Lahore

Dakshita SINGH
July 2015

Xu Tan: Keywords of Cowin Global
Xu Tan: Keywords of Cowin Global
Monograph

Xu Tan: Keywords of Cowin Global

徐坦:“科雲“的詞
2010

Apichatpong Weerasethakul Sourcebook: The Serenity of Madness
Apichatpong Weerasethakul Sourcebook: The Serenity of Madness
Monograph

Apichatpong Weerasethakul Sourcebook: The Serenity of Madness

2016

Discordant_Harmony
Discordant Harmony: Critical Reflection on the Imagination of Asia
Exhibition Catalogue

Discordant Harmony: Critical Reflection on the Imagination of Asia

失調的和諧:關於亞洲想像的批判反思
2016